The Lineup! A Gritty Crime Drama Featuring A Brilliant Performance By Elliot Reid And A Haunting Noir Atmosphere?

1957 was a fascinating year for cinema, marked by the transition from classic Hollywood to the more experimental filmmaking of the French New Wave. While many remember 1957 for iconic films like “12 Angry Men” and “The Bridge on the River Kwai,” a lesser-known gem emerged from this period: the gripping crime drama “The Lineup.”

This television series, airing on CBS from 1954 to 1960, captivated audiences with its noir sensibilities and stark realism. Set in San Francisco’s bustling underworld, “The Lineup” followed the exploits of two detectives: veteran Lieutenant Ben Guthrie, portrayed by the legendary Elliot Reid, and his younger partner, the quick-witted Officer Frank Monahan, played by Robert Rockwell.

Each episode plunged viewers into a shadowy world of murder, blackmail, and betrayal, drawing inspiration from real-life police files and newspaper accounts. The show’s writers, including future television titans like Stirling Silliphant (“Route 66,” “The Twilight Zone”) and Harold Swindle (“Naked City”), crafted intricate plots that kept audiences on the edge of their seats.

But it was Elliot Reid’s performance as Lieutenant Guthrie that truly elevated “The Lineup” from a standard police procedural to something far more memorable. Reid, with his world-weary eyes and gravelly voice, perfectly embodied the cynicism and experience of a man who had seen the darkest side of humanity. He portrayed Guthrie not just as a tough cop but also as a flawed individual grappling with the moral complexities of his job.

Here’s why “The Lineup” deserves rediscovery:

• Gritty Realism: Unlike many crime dramas of the era, “The Lineup” eschewed glamorization and presented a raw and unflinching view of crime and its consequences. The show tackled social issues like corruption, racism, and poverty, reflecting the anxieties of a nation grappling with Cold War tensions and social change.

• Innovative Storytelling: Each episode featured a self-contained story, allowing viewers to delve into diverse criminal cases without needing to follow a complex overarching narrative. This episodic format, coupled with the show’s realistic dialogue and authentic locations, gave “The Lineup” a documentary-like quality that resonated with audiences.

• Elliot Reid’s Commanding Performance: Reid’s portrayal of Lieutenant Guthrie remains one of the most compelling performances in television history. He imbued the character with a depth and complexity rarely seen in crime dramas of the time. Guthrie wasn’t just a stereotypical tough guy; he was a man haunted by his past, struggling to maintain his integrity amidst the moral ambiguity of police work.

• Haunting Noir Atmosphere: “The Lineup” effectively captured the visual aesthetics and thematic elements of film noir. The show employed moody lighting, shadowy compositions, and a stark black-and-white aesthetic that underscored the grim realities of San Francisco’s criminal underworld.

Behind the Scenes: A Look at the Production

• The Origins: Created by Stirling Silliphant and producer Ralph F. Berkowitz (known for “The Lone Ranger” and “Dragnet”), “The Lineup” was initially conceived as a radio series before transitioning to television in 1954.

• Filming Locations: “The Lineup” was primarily filmed on location in San Francisco, capturing the city’s iconic landmarks and gritty neighborhoods. This authenticity contributed to the show’s sense of realism and groundedness.

• Legacy: Although “The Lineup” ended its run in 1960, it left a lasting impact on television crime dramas. The show’s innovative storytelling techniques, gritty realism, and Elliot Reid’s unforgettable performance paved the way for future police procedurals like “Dragnet,” “Hawaii Five-O,” and “Law & Order.”

“The Lineup,” with its noir atmosphere, compelling characters, and unflinching portrayal of crime, remains a fascinating artifact from television’s early days. It offers a glimpse into a bygone era while still resonating with audiences today through its timeless themes of justice, morality, and the human condition.

If you’re looking for a classic crime drama that will keep you on the edge of your seat, then “The Lineup” is definitely worth checking out.